Country Songs of Love Gone Wrong Part I
77
Are you heartbroken? Maybe you have an anniversary or Valentine’s Day coming up, but don’t have anything to celebrate. Maybe you’re sad and don’t want to be cheered up? Or maybe you just appreciate a good song. Well, these Country Music classics are for you. Some consider them love songs. I consider them more “love gone wrong” songs. My dad calls them “cry in your beer” songs.
Songs featured in this hub:
He Stopped Loving Her Today, George Jones
I Fall to Pieces, Patsy Cline
I Can’t Help it if I’m Still in Love with You, Hank Williams
Today I Started Loving You Again, Merle Haggard
Jolene, Dolly Parton
Ruby Don’t Take Your Love to Town, Kenny Rogers and the First Edition
DIVORCE, Tammy Wynette
Crystal Chandelier, Charlie Pride
He Stopped Loving Her Today, George Jones
He Stopped Loving Her Today, recorded by George Jones in 1980 on his album I Am What I Am, revived his stalled career. The song won Grammy, Academy of Country Music, and Country Music Association awards.
He Stopped Loving Her Today was written by Curly Putman and Bobby Braddock, has often been sited as the best country song of all time. It is the incredibly sad story of a man who lost the woman he loved, and only stopped loving her by dying.
George Jones was born in 1931. He is often called “the greatest living country singer”. He is masterful at conveying the feelings contained in lyrics, and is credited with over 150 hit songs. Jones is known for his easily recognizable voice and his musical phrasing. He is also known for his tumultuous relationships, especially with fellow country music superstar and former wife, Tammy Wynette.
I Fall to Pieces, Patsy Cline
I Fall to Pieces was recorded by Patsy Cline for her 1961 release Patsy Cline Showcase. It was a huge hit for Cline, and considered a country standard. The song was written by Harlan Howard and Hank Cochran, who went on to write numerous songs, both singly and together, for Cline.
Patsy Cline was born in 1932, and died in a private plane crash in 1963 at the peak of her career. Despite her relatively short career, she is considered one of the most successful female country artists with far-reaching impact.
I Can’t Help it if I’m Still in Love with You, Hank Williams
Hank Williams was born in 1923, and died at age 29 in 1953. Williams was a prolific songwriter, and considered a pioneer of honky tonk music. Williams grew up in Alabama, and began singing at a local radio station in 1937. By 1941 his drinking was already problematic, and he had difficulty keeping band members after his original band members were drafted. It is reported that his idol, Roy Acuff once told him, "You've got a million-dollar voice, son, but a ten-cent brain." Williams was eventually fired from the Grand Ole Opry.
Williams produced 11 number one songs, and numerous other top ten hits. He battled addictions to alcohol, morphine and other pain killers. He was reported to have an undiagnosed case of spina bifida occulta, which caused him pain. He had rocky relationships with women, including first wife Audrey Sheppard, mother of Randall Hank Williams, aka Hank Williams Jr. Hank Williams had a daughter, Jett Williams, who is also a singer, as are 3 grandchildren. Quite a legacy.
I Can’t Help It If I’m Still In Love With You is but one of many sad, mournful Williams songs. Try these out for cry in your beer lyrics: “Today I passed you on the street, and my heart fell at your feet. I can’t help it if I’m still in love with you.”
Today I Started Loving You Again, Merle Haggard
Merle Haggard was born in 1937 in California. His father died when he was 9 years old. Haggard was first sent to a juvenile detention center at age 13 for truancy and various petty offenses. He continued the same behaviors, and was detained a total of 4 times. In 1957 he burglarized a tavern and was sent to San Quentin where he saw Johnny Cash perform 3 times. In prison he decided to turn his life around.
Haggard started recording music in 1962 and had his first of 38 number one hits in 1966. Haggard and his band The Strangers, along with Buck Owens are credited with popularizing “the Bakersfield sound” in Nashville. Today I Started Loving You Again was not a number one hit, but still a great song with lyrics: “I got over you just long enough to let my heartache end. And then today, I started loving you again.”
Dolly sings Jolene on The Porter Wagoner Show
More recent Dolly singing Jolene with Miley Cyrus
Jolene, Dolly Parton
Dolly Parton was born in Tennessee in 1946, and grew up, in her words, “dirt poor”. She has been married to her husband, Carl since 1966. She joined The Porter Wagoner Show in 1967, and continued appearances and recording with Wagoner until 1976.
Jolene was written and recorded by Parton, and released as a single in 1973, before the release of the album Jolene in 1974. The song is about a homemaker who pleads with a beautiful, sexy siren “I’m begging of you please don’t take my man”. Parton has said the inspiration for the song was a pretty, red-headed bank teller who flirted with her husband. The name “Jolene” was from a young red-headed autograph seeker.
Parton has 25 number one singles, and 40 top ten country albums. Jolene ranked 217 in Rolling Stone’s 500 greatest songs of all time. It has been recorded countless times by artists from diverse musical stylings.
Ruby Don’t Take Your Love to Town, Kenny Rogers and the First Edition
The First Edition formed in 1967. Ruby, released in 1969, was a hit around the glove. The band changed their name to Kenny Rogers and the First Edition. The song is about an injured and paralyzed veteran, pleading with his woman not to step out on him, “Ruby, don’t take your love to town”. It was considered bold and risky to release such a song during the Viet Nam conflict.
The First Editions had their own TV variety show from 1971 to 1975. Also in 1975, Kenny Rogers signed as a solo artist with United Artists. Rogers went on to have a hugely successful solo career.
D-I-V-O-R-C-E, Tammy Wynette
Tammy Wynette was born Virginia Wynette Pugh in 1942. Her father, a musician and farmer, died when she was 9 months old. Her mother moved to Memphis to work at a WWII defense plant. “Wynette” was raised by her maternal grandparents in Mississippi, near the Alabama border. She was a basketball star in high school. She was married to a construction worker who had difficulty keeping work. She left him when she was pregnant with her 3rd child. She obtained a cosmetology license, which she maintained the rest of her life.
Wynette, who sang and played some of her father’s instruments, did guest spots on Porter Wagoner before being signed by Epic Records in 1966. She received her first Grammy in 1967. She had five number one hits in 1968-1969, including D-I-V-O-R-C-E, written by Curly Putman and Bobby Braddock. Braddock is a long time friend of our very own Tom Cornett and TamCor.
In all, Wynette had 17 number one singles, and was named Country Music Associations’ Female Vocalist of the Year three times.
Tammy Wynette was married to George Jones from 1969-1975. They had a volatile relationship, attributed t Jones’ alcohol and drug abuse. They had a daughter together and continued recording together until 1980, and sporadically after that. Wynette died in 1998, after years of medical problems.
![]() | Contains Crystal Chandeliers Amazon Price: $19.00 List Price: $11.98 |
![]() | Tribute to Hank Williams Amazon Price: $85.00 List Price: $6.98 |
Crystal Chandeliers, Charley Pride
Charley Pride was born in 1938 in Mississippi, one of 11 children to sharecropper parents. Although he began playing guitar in his teens, he also had a love for baseball. He began playing minor league baseball for the Negro League in 1952. After a 2 year military stint, he had difficulty pursuing a continued career in baseball.
He started pursuing music in earnest, and was signed by RCA in 1966. He released moderately successful singles over the next year, before his 3rd single, Just Between You and Me, which won a Grammy. He is the only African American inducted into the Grand Ole Opry. He was named Country Music Association Entertainer of the Year 1971, and CMA Male Vocalist of the Year 1971 &1972. He was inducted into the Country Music Hall of Fame in 2000. Charley has had 36 number one hits. He joins the Texas Rangers each year to work out for Spring Training.
My Music Hubs
Hallelujah- 10 Performance Videos of Leonard Cohen’s Much-Loved Song
Hallelujah- More Performance Videos of Leonard Cohen’s Much-Loved Song
Hallelujah- Idol and X-Factor Video Performances of Leonard Cohen’s Song
Hallelujah- Video Performance Gems of Leonard Cohen’s Song by International Artists
Romantic Songs- Favorite Country Music Love Songs
Country Songs of Love Gone Wrong Part I
Irish Rock Bands: Bob Geldof of the Boomtown Rats
My Favorite British Rock Bands (with videos), Part I- The Beatles, Pink Floyd, and Black Sabbath
My Favorite British Rock Bands (with videos), Part II- Zeppelin, Queen, the Who, and the Stones
Paul Anka’s You’re Having My Baby- Romantic or Chauvinistic?
Now "Jolene" is a classic - I love that song - great Hub, as usual.
Great hub! Bobby Braddock also wrote D-I-V-O-R-C-E. He is and old friend of ours. He thought that "He Stopped Loving Her Today" was too sad to be a hit....until he heard George Jones sing it. Bobby is still writing and co-writing hits...."God is Great, Beer is Good and People are Crazy."
Again....great hub! :)
Thanks rmcrayne....Bobby is a great guy... one of the many wonderful friendships we made when we lived in Nashville. He use to tell us the most recent songwriter jokes...like.."What's the difference between a songwriter and a pizza?....A pizza can feed a family of four. :)
Great songs. I cannot listen to DIVORCE though without thinking of Billy Connolly's comedy rendition.
I love Merle, Dolly, and KEnny. I also like funny love-gone-bad songs like "Queen of My Double-Wide Trailer." I enjoy just about every kind of music! Enjoyed the read!
Great background information on these performers. I didn't know about Merle Haggard being in prison and seeing Johnny Cash perform there. I listened to a lot of this music growing up as my dad was a big country music fan. I love Patsy Cline and also the George Jones song you mentioned.
RM, my ex in-laws raise the same kind of cattle Kenny did. They went to his farm and didn't even get his autograph! My sister-in-law and I couldn't believe it!
Great list. Great hub. Another song that was too sad to be a hit was "Whiskey Lullaby". Paisley and Krauss. What a song!
I really hate todays country.
---> Other then Reba :D
Great hub I love all these songs especially George Jones. Looking forward to reading more hubs from you. Good job.
Another great hub. "I Fall to Pieces" by Patsy Cline is one of my personal favorites. Thanks for including it.
I really enjoyed this hub RM, I'm a huge fan of country music. It's funny how, whenever I feel like my relationship is going bad, I can listen to really sad country songs and somehow feel better afterwards.




































Lily Rose Level 2 Commenter 2 years ago
Those are some great songs, Rose Mary! When I read the title to your hub, the first song that came to my mind was "Fancy" by Reba - not exactly along the same tone, but definitely love gone wrong!